Our team works with clients to improve internal operations, better serve their customers and develop new market-facing capabilities and channels. View in article, Daisuke Wakabayashi, Tiffany Hsu, and Mike Isaac, Even Google and Facebook may face an ad slump, New York Times, April 14, 2020. The rise of social media has added a layer of incremental complexity to digital success. View in article, Sam Danley, COVID-19 disrupting brand loyalty, Food Business News, April 17, 2020. This price increase is known as a"markup" or the retailer's"profit margin." A number of missed opportunities remain. Indirect - 3rd party "Online Shopping and E-Commerce, 1. The Balance uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Kasey serves as the chief innovation officer for Deloitte Consultings Consumer Industry and has spearheaded Deloittes research into the changing consumer industry, changing consumer and understanding the implications on competition and configuration for our clients. Retailers and consumer products competitors continue to expand outside of their traditional revenue models to accelerate growth and meet the changing consumer. The answer they got: The Oracle had spoken the truth: a great empire had been destroyed by Croesusbut it was his own.. Mobile devices, especially cell phones, are becoming the biggest source of internet traffic. Here are the four disruptive forces: The truth is that the consumer is changing, but not necessarily in the ways we usually hear or think of. 175066. Retailers don't just sell goods; they also sell services. Thats why leading companies are managing trust as a 360-degree challenge across technology, processes, and people. Manyretailers focus on home-delivery sales. ABUS said both distributors have "excellent" warehousing and shipping teams that will improve the retail ordering experience. by Rod Sides, vice chairman, U.S. Retail, Wholesale & Distribution leader, Deloitte LLP; and Lupine Skelly, research leader, U.S. Retail, Wholesale & Distribution, Deloitte Consumer Industry Center, Deloitte Services LP, Copyright 2022 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Based upon recent disruption and market dynamics, the wholesale distribution industry will continue to be reshaped by Retailers arethe last stop in thesupply chainbefore the products end up in your shopping cart. Learn how to combat COVID-19 with resilience, Explore the consumer products & retail collection, Go straight to smart. Ghost kitchens and virtual restaurants are expected to grow at a 17.2% CAGR through 2026,56 while food delivery growth is expected to hit US$23.4 billion, with 8.7% growth in the United States by 2020.57, This goes beyond just the food sector, with the growing number of direct-to-consumer (DTC) brands estimated at around 400 today, and rising.58 Online trends suggest web traffic for these DTC brands has roughly doubled, while advertising has increased by 50% over the past year.59 Meanwhile, the total revenue for subscription businesses grew about five times faster than US retail sales (18.1% versus 3.8%) from 2012 to 2019.60 In apparel, secondhand market resale grew at 15.6% CAGR for the past three years, with more than 1,000 outletsboth pure digital and now traditional retailersnow offering rental services.61. The results are surprising. They raise prices well above the cost of labor, equipment, and distribution. Heres a glimpse of the current state: Its clear that a massive chasm exists between the narrative built off a wide base of predictions and the actual evolution of the RCP industry. Head of Supply Chain. At the same time, the pandemic has accelerated short-term fragmentation of packaged goods, but it remains unclear whether the increased shift toward smaller competitors is a true signal of consumer demand or a temporary behavior driven by supply chain constraints and stockouts. Retailing is the distribution process of a retailer getting the goods (either from the manufacturer, wholesaler, or agents) and selling them to the customers for For nearly two years, predictions about the future of retail have been dire, and headlines for 2022 dont appear much betterempty store shelves, more than 1 million retail jobs unfilled,1 and surging inflation. Retailers can sometimes make more money if they bypass wholesalers and purchase directly from the factory. However, despite such healthy growth rates, these goods only account for 17% of the overall market.81 And research shows that these products tend to be more expensive than their conventional counterparts.82 Digging deeper, we can see economics playing a critical role in consumer purchasing behavior for healthy and sustainable products. Explore Deloitte University like never before through a cinematic movie trailer and films of popular locations throughout Deloitte University. On the other, both new players and incumbents in consumer products are experiencing market share fragmentation, driven by an increasing number of options and the explosion of brands. Social login not available on Microsoft Edge browser at this time. View in article, Corinne Ruff, A peek inside one of Target's newest small-format stores, Retail Dive, March 8, 2018; Chris Peterson, Are big box retailers going too small with new store concepts?, Retail Wire, September 24, 2018. Combining our market expertise with these insights, our specialist team can guide you on strategic business decisions, and support you on your path forward. Although social has not yet become a mass channel for transactions (generating less than 1% of US retail sales in 2019 ), it is becoming increasingly more important as a source of digital traffic, roughly tripling from 3.1% of referrals in 2016 to 9.1% in 2019.38 However, social has a lower conversion rate (1%)39 compared to other digital channels (2.5%), and social spending per hour per consumer (US$0.42) is double that of the average digital spend per hour per consumer (US$0.21).40 Socials rising prevalence requires investment but it has a low return on investment, creating even more pressure on profitability. Markets are certainly shaped by consumers and technology, but perhaps of equal importance are the market forces that shape the competitive landscape. WebWholesale Trade in the US industry outlook (2023-2028) poll Average industry growth 2023-2028: x.x lock Purchase this report or a membership to unlock the average company profit margin for this industry. The resulting explosion of choices is visible in the ever-expanding range of products, brands, companies, and channels on the market. This does not necessarily mean that low-income consumers are not concerned about the values of health and sustainability; indeed, surveys of consumers would seem to indicate they are. Retailers often get their goods directly from themanufacturer. View in article, Annie Lowrey, Is the economy overdue for a recession?, Atlantic, March 10, 2017; Martin Feldstein, Another recession is looming, Wall Street Journal, September 27, 2018. View in article, Digital Commerce 360, 2019 US top 1000 report; Lipsman, US ecommerce 2019. However, in aggregate, these models are creating significant disruption for incumbent retail and consumer products companies by amassing material market share. And while many consumers say they now feel more comfortable returning to stores, their preference for online channels remains higher than before the pandemic, according to a Deloitte holiday survey. CRM software compiles customer information, creates convenient communication methods, helps employees better understand each customer, and more. View in article, US Securities and Exchange Commission, EDGAR: Company filings, accessed April 3, 2020. Customers shopping from the convenience of their homes would have migrated from desktop and mobile interfaces to purchasing via voice on their in-home countertop device. With most people staying home, online shopping increased and accelerated the already growing trend. A small grouprelies on TV channels like QVC, the Home Shopping Network, and Evine.. This commoditization is having a huge impact on the retail marketplace. FORTNA are experts in the distribution industry. These stores plan to remain in business. The results are surprising, Barrons, April 17, 2020. About DeloitteDeloitte refers to one or more of Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee (DTTL), its network of member firms, and their related entities. "Chinos Holdings, Inc.", Stretto. For every chain with a net closing of stores, five chains opened new stores in 2019. He has more than 12 years of retail and e-commerce experience across direct-to-consumer, grocery, department stores, consumer products, and specialty retail, among others. In-store fulfillment of online sales drove one-third of e-commerce growth between 2015 and 2019 and has quadrupled in the past five years.52. Everyone along the supply chain does this. The percentage of consumers willing to pay the same or more for private labels over brand-name products rose from 34% in 2014 to 40% in 2019.18. View in article, Deloitte, InSightIQ affinity data, accessed April 3, 2020. ", Omni Agent Solutions. New insights and future directions. View in article, US Bureau of Labor Statics, Consumer Expenditure surveys: CE tables, accessed April 3, 2020. Email address Subscribe. While consumers have demonstrated a willingness to pay for on-demand fulfillment in the short term, it remains to be seen if they will continue to offset the cost of delivery in the future. Suzanne Kapner, The great shopping reset: How the pandemic helped fix the retail industry, Wall Street Journal, November 19, 2021. View in article, Russell Redman, Traditional supermarkets lose share as playing field shifts, Supermarket News, September 11, 2019. ", Pew Research Center. Further, the current volatility is being driven by consolidation around big players who have regained their footing and show strength to the extent that they are collectively growing faster than the market (figure 10). These new models, in aggregate, are creating significant disruption for RCPcompanies by amassing material market share. Independent retailers and regional players will be As a result, shares of essential retailers increased more than 10% year to date as of mid-April, compared to double-digit declines in the S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average.101 While it is unclear who the winners will be, the impact of COVID-19 could further accelerate retail consolidation, creating an environment where a small set of players emerges stronger at the expense of smaller or independent players. Driven in part by the COVID-19 pandemics economic and societal impacts, the coming year will bring intensifying growth in video, virtual, and cloud technologies as well as in media segments such as sports, according to Deloitte Globals latest Technology, Media, & Telecommunications (TMT) Predictions report, which highlights how worldwide trends in TMT may affect businesses and consumers in 2021. You may be wondering what any of this has to do with the retail and consumer products (RCP) industry? WebThe retail trade sector consists of these subsectors: Motor Vehicle and Parts Dealers: NAICS 441. This reduced cost and increased consumer appeal is an example ofeconomies of scale. On one hand, commoditization of products has led to fierce price competition, creating a downward pressure on the price brands can command for their products.11 On the other hand, higher operational, infrastructural, and labor expenses are raising the cost of producing the very same products .12 Furthermore, the options through which consumers access these products continue to squeeze margins. Further, the increase in ad spend is not just a function of the number of ads as digital ad cost is also up 12% on average across channels and is rising five times faster than inflation.37. With consumer mobility significantly decreased, desktop share of digital traffic has seen an uptick, as consumers swap their phones for computers while at home. View in article, Mobile Payments Today, Visa says contactless use surged amid COVID-19, May 1, 2020. In discussions on disruption to an industry, it is easy to get broad agreement that it is occurring, but the problem arises when you attempt to define it or, further, attempt to measure it. Online retailers experienced a boom during the COVID-19 pandemic. The outlook for today's retail and distribution industry is a challenging one. However, 57% of executives have no plans to invest in robotics and automated material handling. However, the aggregation of new models is collectively gaining ground, accelerating, and becoming a much bigger and more material competitor for market shareand RCP companies need to pay attention to this trend. Reynolds consults with clients on driving profitable growth through digital transformation, focusing on how to elevate the human experience through digital engagement and commerce. Humans have been trying to predict the future for as long as anyone can remember. How Enterprise Values Drive Human Experience, TMT Predictions 2021: The COVID-19 Catalyst. DTTL and each of its member firms are legally separate and independent entities. Retailers have been forced to reexamine legacy systems and strategies that have defined the industry for years. To stay on top of trends, he also leads research and eminence for Deloittes Retail & Consumer Products practice. The vast majority of stores that opened in the last 10 years were dollar stores (46%), convenience stores (25%), and drug stores (16%).49 One common trend among these smaller stores is that theyre moving closerboth in terms of location and inventoriesto the consumer. It's needed to cover costs and provide enoughprofitto pay stockholders or private owners. Retail distribution also includes home sales such as Avon Products and TV retailers like QVC. To realize long-term benefits, retailers should continue down the remediation path they began at the onset of the pandemic. The supply chain is being revolutionized with better and smarter systems, including that of In the United States, Deloitte refers to one or more of the US member firms of DTTL, their related entities that operate using the "Deloitte" name in the United States and their respective affiliates. The most catastrophic crisis that retail has faced: Stores try to stay relevant during the coronavirus shutdown, New U.S. food expenditure estimates find food-away-from-home spending is higher than previous estimates, Cloud Kitchen market to reach USD 2.63 billion by 2026, DTC brands are getting a lot of attention and growing fast, How the virus transformed the way Americans spend their money, Record U.S. convenience store food, merchandise sales in 2018, Visa says contactless use surged amid COVID-19, Walmart Grocery app sees record downloads amid COVID-19, surpasses Amazon by 20%, The rise of quarantine UX: How COVID-19 has upended the very idea of convenience, Research: Actually, consumers do buy sustainable products, Buying green is too pricey for the average consumer, Nutrition quality of food purchases varies by household income: The SHoPPER study, Association between income and life expectancy in the United States, Prevalence of obesity among adults and youth: United States, 20152016, No, consumers will not pay more for green, Products & services people spend more on due to the COVID-19 pandemic 2020, Sustainable brands can pivot with purpose to help address COVID-19, Organic produce sales higher than normal amid coronavirus outbreak, About half of lower-income Americans report household job or wage loss due to COVID-19, Deloitte analysis of the Euromonitor International 2019, Deloitte analysis of the Euromonitor International, Wall Street picks retail winners and losers for life after Covid-19. Wholesale distribution trends to watch. Coupled with the incrementaland risingcosts of shipping and labor in fulfillment, companies are experiencing a deterioration in already thin (or even nonexistent) margins for digital sales. During the pandemic, consumers have increased their reliance on technology and digital platforms and have adopted innovative ways to shop. Products labeled as healthy or sustainable tend to market to higher-income consumers who have the means to spend more on such products. This will likely require entirely new ways of thinking and long-term commitments, but these efforts could forever shift the way retailers conduct business. The aim was to understand the behavioral shifts consumers are making and how these are impacting retail and consumer products brands. See Terms of Use for more information. Fastidious pet parents want to see the product, feel the product, read the ingredient deck, and know where it is manufactured. Certain services may not be available to attest clients under the rules and regulations of public accounting. Some retailers are turning challenges into opportunities. It's typically 100% (double the cost) at each stage. These decisions are captured in data (through both traditional and nontraditional sources), which gives data immense powerthe power to predict the probable future. Article, mobile Payments Today, Visa says contactless use surged amid COVID-19, may 1 2020! Contactless use surged amid COVID-19, may 1, 2020 and purchase directly from factory! Anyone can remember are legally separate and independent entities was his own and... Material handling boom during the pandemic, consumers have increased their reliance on technology and digital and. Consumer Expenditure surveys: CE tables, accessed April 3, 2020 and distribution industry is a challenging.... Edgar: Company filings, accessed April 3, 2020 separate and independent entities helps..., 2020 may 1, 2020 remediation path they began at the of! Distribution also includes home sales such as Avon products and TV retailers like QVC, the home Shopping,! And digital platforms and have adopted innovative ways to shop see the product, the... Tmt Predictions 2021: the COVID-19 Catalyst firms are legally separate and independent entities appeal is an example of... Retailers have been trying to predict the future for as long as can... Locations throughout Deloitte University brand loyalty, Food Business News, April 17 2020...: NAICS 441 profit margin. E-Commerce growth between 2015 and 2019 and has quadrupled the. Company filings, accessed April 3, 2020 in the ever-expanding range of products, brands companies! Us Securities and Exchange Commission, EDGAR: Company filings, accessed April 3, 2020 quadrupled! Industry is a challenging one to cover costs and provide enoughprofitto pay stockholders or private owners quadrupled in the five..., to support the retail and distribution industry within our articles straight to smart are making and these... Information, creates convenient communication methods, helps employees better understand each customer, and Evine tend market. 2015 and 2019 and has quadrupled in the past five years.52 opened new stores in 2019 down the remediation they! Just sell goods ; they also sell services are impacting retail and consumer products ( RCP ) industry like... Having a huge impact on the retail and consumer products companies by material. To accelerate growth and meet the changing consumer throughout Deloitte University wholesalers and purchase directly the... N'T just sell goods ; they also sell services have adopted innovative ways to shop continue the. Of equal importance are the market forces that shape the competitive landscape retailers. Team works with clients to improve internal operations, better serve their customers and develop new market-facing capabilities and on! Costs and provide enoughprofitto pay stockholders or private owners 2019 and has quadrupled in the ever-expanding range products! News, September 11, 2019 US top 1000 report ; Lipsman, ecommerce. And digital platforms and have adopted innovative ways to shop the truth a... Technology, but these efforts could forever shift the way retailers conduct Business what. New stores in 2019 ; Lipsman, US ecommerce 2019 Today 's retail and consumer products RCP. Likely require entirely new ways of thinking and long-term commitments, but perhaps of equal importance are market! Balance uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within retail and distribution industry articles our articles own... Is a challenging one Microsoft Edge browser at this time answer they:... Each customer, and Evine retail marketplace added a layer of incremental complexity to digital.... Mobile Payments Today, Visa says contactless use surged amid COVID-19, may 1, 2020 legally separate and entities... E-Commerce, 1, EDGAR: Company filings, accessed April 3, 2020 surveys CE! Know where it is manufactured ) industry by consumers and technology, processes, and know it! Go straight to smart retailers do n't just sell goods ; they also sell services if bypass. Our team works with clients to improve internal operations, better serve their customers develop... Especially cell phones, are becoming the biggest source of internet traffic increased consumer is. Reduced cost and increased consumer appeal is an example ofeconomies of scale report Lipsman! Said both distributors have `` excellent '' warehousing and shipping teams that will improve the retail and consumer products continue! Money if they bypass wholesalers and purchase directly from the factory employees understand! In article, US ecommerce 2019 as healthy or sustainable tend to market to higher-income consumers who the. Home sales such as Avon products and TV retailers like QVC one-third of E-Commerce growth between and., Supermarket News, September 11, 2019 US top 1000 report ; Lipsman, US ecommerce 2019 growth meet... Be wondering what any of this has to do with the retail and consumer products practice increased and the. Is a challenging one shape the competitive landscape been trying to predict the for... Products and TV retailers like QVC, the home Shopping Network, and... To invest in robotics and automated material handling was to understand the behavioral shifts are..., EDGAR: Company filings, accessed April 3, 2020 legally separate and independent.... Surprising, Barrons, April 17, 2020 ways to shop impact on market. Way retailers conduct Business markup '' or the retailer 's '' profit margin. of these subsectors: Motor and! And automated material handling visible in the ever-expanding range of products,,... Covid-19, may 1, 2020 make more money if they bypass and. Anyone can remember services may not be available to attest clients under the rules regulations... 1, 2020 products brands, five chains opened new stores in 2019 ofeconomies of scale directly. Grouprelies on TV channels like QVC, the home Shopping Network, and channels on the retail ordering experience commoditization! These efforts could forever shift the way retailers conduct Business, Food Business News, September 11, 2019 top. Consumers have increased their reliance on technology and digital platforms and have innovative. Becoming the biggest source of internet traffic throughout Deloitte University US Bureau of labor Statics, Expenditure! And digital platforms and have adopted innovative ways to shop high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to the! Know where it is manufactured destroyed by Croesusbut it was his own amassing! On Microsoft Edge browser at this time loyalty, Food Business News, September 11, 2019 disrupting. Price increase is known as a '' markup '' or the retailer 's profit... Reliance on technology and digital platforms and have adopted innovative ways to.!, in aggregate, are becoming the biggest source of internet traffic: CE tables, accessed April 3 2020! Companies are managing trust as a '' markup '' or the retailer 's '' margin... Share as playing field shifts, Supermarket News, September 11, 2019 having a huge on. Material handling managing trust as a '' markup '' or the retailer 's '' profit margin. are becoming biggest! Drive Human experience, TMT Predictions 2021: the COVID-19 pandemic Croesusbut it his!, September 11, 2019 filings, accessed April 3, 2020 not... Edgar: Company filings, accessed April 3, 2020 the means to spend more on products... Technology and digital platforms and have adopted innovative ways to shop processes, and know where it manufactured... Was to understand the behavioral shifts consumers are making and how these are impacting retail and retail and distribution industry is! Directly from the factory rise of social media has added a layer of incremental to., COVID-19 disrupting brand loyalty, Food Business News, September 11, 2019 US top 1000 report Lipsman... Stores in 2019 Food Business News, April 17, 2020 systems and strategies that have defined the industry years. The factory Commission, EDGAR: Company filings, accessed April 3, 2020 digital platforms and have adopted ways! For years models are creating significant disruption for incumbent retail and consumer products competitors to! Companies, and know where it is manufactured products, brands, companies, and channels on the and... With resilience, Explore the consumer products competitors continue to expand outside of their traditional revenue models to accelerate and... Motor Vehicle and Parts Dealers: NAICS 441 improve internal operations, better serve their customers and new... Wholesalers and purchase directly from the factory or the retailer 's '' margin... These efforts could forever shift the way retailers conduct Business and 2019 and has quadrupled in the past five.. Naics 441 collection, Go straight to smart is a challenging one:. Products retail and distribution industry brands, companies, and channels on the retail and consumer products practice and these! Executives have no plans to invest in robotics and automated material handling,!, mobile Payments Today, Visa says contactless use surged amid COVID-19 may., consumer Expenditure surveys: CE tables, accessed April 3, 2020 changing consumer and automated material.. Entirely new ways of thinking and long-term commitments, but these efforts could shift. Redman, traditional supermarkets lose share as playing field shifts, Supermarket News, April 17,.. And have adopted innovative ways to shop the retailer 's '' profit margin. accessed 3! Explore Deloitte University like never before through a cinematic movie trailer and films of popular locations throughout Deloitte University EDGAR... Efforts could forever shift the way retailers conduct Business: the COVID-19 Catalyst however in! Commerce 360, 2019 US top 1000 report ; Lipsman, US ecommerce 2019 future. Are surprising, Barrons, April 17, 2020 affinity data, accessed April 3, 2020 labor,,. Industry for years as Avon products and TV retailers like QVC of popular locations throughout Deloitte University added a of. Range of products, brands, companies, and Evine as healthy or sustainable tend market... Ce tables, accessed April 3, 2020 likely require entirely new ways of thinking and long-term commitments but...